Tuesday, July 10, 2007

Watchpoodles?

Dan Kimball almost always writes stuff worth reading. Today is no exception. As a member of the "emerging" church, he sometimes takes flack. I found this comparison interesting (and too accurate):

I have found it at times fascinating, strange, helpful and hurtful when certain watchdog types of Christians write on blogs pretty mean things about other Christians and 98% of the time they are grossly inaccurate. I am aware that it is a pretty small slice of Christians who think like that and do those things, but as my theory goes - the small % are the most vocal ones. At first I was caught off guard by the tone and spirit of the "watchdogs" as I had never experienced that level of tone and words from Christians before. But then I realized, most of them are just trying their best in their own way to protect what they feel should be protected. But after reading enough of how many of them think, they really aren't watchdogs as in trained watch dogs like Doberman pinschers, but are more like little barking poodles. I like poodles actually. But the tiny ones sure can be mean and bark loudly and bare their fangs at anyone who doesn't live in their home. We owned a poodle growing up, so I have seen how you could have your best friend over and even relatives over, but the poodle didn't like anyone they were unfamiliar with. Poodles would then bark and growl in the way little poodles do even at friends and family members. It seems that many of the "watchdogs" out there, are like the poodle where they growl and bark at anything that is unfamiliar to them - even if it is the best friends or other family members of the family they live with. The poodle has good intentions, but anyone different and unfamiliar that isn't in their particular world or way of thinking gets barked and growled at.


He goes on to reflect on how Hudson Taylor took a lot of flack for his unorthodox presentation of very orthodox Christianity. Please, do yourself a favor and read the whole thing.

2 comments:

Ted M. Gossard said...

The biggest danger I think is for us to become like them in our response. Dan isn't doing that here, but I have before, and that doesn't help.

jps said...

Ted,

You are very correct. It is too easy to become self-righteous in return instead of reacting in love.

James